By Truce Podcast | Listen | 37m
Published in March of 2021
SUMMARY: Was America founded as a Christian nation? That depends on how you define Christian and how you define nation. In the 1800s did most of the population identify as Christian? Yes. Was this also a time when 1/3 of the population was in forced labor? Yes. Was this also a time when the majority of the population attended church? Yes. Was this a time when laws and social norms discriminated against Native Americans, black people, Catholics, and many other groups? Yes. Host Chris Staron illustrates that the claim that America was founded as a Christian nation or the statement that we need to “get back to being a Christian nation” is dubious. American history bears witness to a vague Christianity. One where people identify with the religion but don’t follow the way of Jesus. Staron calls this the battle between the economic Jesus and the servant Jesus.
KEY QUOTES: “I grew up with a sense of American exceptionalism…The idea that this was a Christian nation was there all the time spread by pastors and talk shows. To question that assumption was seen as questioning the Bible itself despite the fact that the United States is not in the Bible. For many of us when we learn about dark hours of American history we question our faith because our religion has been tied to the stars and stripes. And the stars and stripes aren’t always doing righteous deeds.”
“Christian America does not fit our history if you worship a Jesus who lays down his life, advocates for the less fortunate, and spends a lot of time hanging out with prostitutes, the sick, and the forgotten. Christian America does fit our history if we see Jesus as a giver of blessings and a guardian who promises to keep us safe. American exceptionalism fits our history if we see Christians as exceptional instead of servants.”
WANT MORE? Sunday to Saturday has curated topical playlists on Listen Notes where you can subscribe and listen to the curated episodes in your favorite podcast player.
DIG DEEPER: We have curated three guided learning paths to help you think distinctly Christian about Christian nationalism.
Our latest curated podcasts on Christian nationalism:
PODCAST: What is Christian Nationalism with Alex Tuckness
In a well-rounded and straightforward conversation lead pastor at Cornerstone Church of Ames (Amex. IA) Mark Vance and Iowa State University professor Alex Tuckness discuss if Christian nationalism is real, how Christian nationalism can be distorted, and the dangers of Christian nationalism in the public square.Read more
PODCAST: Glenn Packiam – The Bible Leaves No Room For Christian Nationalism
New Life Church (Colorado Springs, CO) pastor Glenn Packiam says pastors need to point out the symptoms of Christian nationalism before providing a diagnosis. Packiam then touches on idolatry, kingdom theology, the global church, and much more in a wide-ranging and nuanced interview.Read more
PODCAST: Paul D. Miller – The Religion of Christian Nationalism
In a succinct and meaty conversation with host Marty Duren Georgetown University professor and author Paul Miller first defines his terms, such as classical liberalism, nationalism, patriotism, and conservatism, before discussing the dangers of nationalism shaping Christians instead of the other way around. Miller concludes the conversation with some advice for pastors addressing Christian nationalism…Read more