SUMMARY: Former gang member Victor Rios grew up in the ghetto of Oakland, California so he knows the realities of Black and Latino males growing up in the ghetto, but this is not his story. Punished: Policing the Lives of Black and Latino Boys is based off of Rios Ph.D. thesis at Berkeley that he penned after spending three years following 40 Black and Latino males in Oakland.
“What this study demonstrates is that the poor, at least in this community, have not been abandoned by the state,” Rios says. “Instead, the state has become deeply embedded in their everyday lives, through the auspices of punitive social control.”
Rios thesis boils down to Black and Latino males in Oakland are put into an endless loop of hypercriminalization and punishment, because of the way they look and sometimes dress, where they are “harassed, profiled, watched, and disciplined at young ages, before they (commit) any crimes.”
It is a system that strips the boys of their dignity while sowing distrust and animosity between the police and the community as the boys are profiled, harassed, and overpoliced the moment they leave their homes.
“The boys in Oakland were not seen as souls that needed to be disciplined but as irreparable risks and threats that needed to be controlled and ultimately contained,” Rios says. “The discipline imposed on the boys in Oakland…stripped them of their dignity and humanity by systematically marking them and denying them the ability to function in school, in the labor market, and as law-abiding citizens.”
Once the boys are in the system it is almost impossible to get out as there are very limited, if any, resources provided by the police, schools, and social programs. This puts the boys in a double bind – if they follow friends and family into crime they will continue to get tangled in the system, but if they do anything involved with the police then their peers see them as a “snitch” and are physically and verbally abused.
“In other words, when the boys sought out dignity, they were often at risk of losing their freedom; when they worked for freedom, they were making an attempt to stay out of jail or prison but often felt that they had lost their dignity in the process.”
Rios’ final chapter calls for the end to mass incarceration (it denies people their humanity), a change to policies and programs so they point to reintegration and restoration (can lead to personal and social transformation; restoring dignity leads to crime suppression), an elimination of zero-tolerance policies (second chances are needed), a limitation on school based policing (police aren’t trained to teach or nurture) and a redistribution of resources from criminal justice institutions into community institutions (a key point of the defund the police movement).
“The more rehabilitative, reintegrative, and positive their interactions with authority figures (are), the more the boys believed in themselves and understood themselves to have a better future,” Rios concludes.
The call for restorative justice, second chances, and dignity and respect for everyone should ring clear and true for Christians and serve as a guide to what Christians can advocate for locally and nationally.
KEY QUOTE: “The ambition in this book is to show the failures of criminalization, the failures of using harsh, stigmatizing, and humiliating forms of punishment to ‘correct’ and ‘manage’ marginalized youths, as well as to highlight the consequences that these methods have on young people’s trajectories. Ultimately, I believe that by understanding the lives of boys who are criminalized and pipelined through the criminal justice system, we can begin to develop empathic solutions which support these young men in their development and to eliminate the culture of criminalization that has become an overbearing part of their everyday lives.”
DID YOU KNOW?: Sunday to Saturday has a Good Reads page where we post all of the books we have read – even the ones that didn’t make the cut.
DIG DEEPER: We have curated four guided learning paths to help you think distinctly Christian about policing.
More curated books on policing:
For those wondering if the issue with policing is a couple of bad officers or if it is the system, 28-year law enforcement veteran Matthew Horace unequivocally paints a picture of a broken system in his memoir The Black and the Blue. Before critiquing the system, Horace unequivocally says he is a cop while also being unequivocally a black man. He has lived on both sides of a police gun.Read more
From rising homelessness that the police are tasked to deal with to shootings of both minorities and police officers to endless mental health issues involving both police officers and the population American police are simply expected to do too much. Author Alex Vitale argues that the structure of American policing, and the U.S. legal system, protects the interests of those in power and/or with money and needs to be dismantled. Simply put, Americans need to rethink the mission of the police and how we police those within the borders of the United States.Read more